Long before I discovered Buxom mascara, Diorshow was my favorite mascara. I own Chestnut Brown, and though there’s not much difference between that and black, I like having the hint of brown for toning down neutral or natural makeup looks. I’ve owned Diorshow since before I wrote reviews, so it always slipped my mind that I HADN’T actually written my feelings on it except in a few comparisons in other mascara reviews.
Diorshow is a nice all-purpose formula. It DOES volumize quite a bit, but it also separates nicely. I’ve never had issues with it flaking, clumping, or smudging. I’ve heard from other makeup users that it does, in hotter climates. So that is something to be aware of. I like it, though. Lashes look dramatic, but not overwhelmingly spiky. It’s perfect to set off smoky eyes.
(sorry for the really old picture. My new ones seem to have gone missing!)
The brush is very full and thick, conventional bristles adn shape. It applies nicely to the lower lashline, but I sometimes have issues reaching the corners of my eyes with it. You don’t NEED to use any special application techniques(Both my other mascara favorites recommend you twist the brush as you apply to get the most separation and fullness). The formula is fairly moist, and with the brush type, product DOES collect on the tip, so be careful not to smudge when applying.
I prefer to use a good primer with it, for even MORE volume. It’s not the most extraordinary mascara I own, but it’s good for when I don’t need anything specific.
I think i’d like it more if it was slightly creamier. This is great for most lash types, but really thick types may have difficulty working it into the lashes, with the brush shape and mascara consistency. Lately, I’ve been using Laura Mercier full blown volume mascara, and Fresh Supernova mascara in situations I used to use Diorshow. The wear is a bit better, adn both apply easier to my lash texture. They don’t hold the lashes curl like Diorshow does, though.